Following the American Civil War Sesquicentennial with day by day writings of the time, currently 1863.

Post image for “What a ‘glorious victory!’ So glorious that we must rush back to camp to announce it, leaving the enemy to look after our killed and wounded! A few such victories would ruin us.”–Journal of Surgeon Alfred L. Castleman.

“What a ‘glorious victory!’ So glorious that we must rush back to camp to announce it, leaving the enemy to look after our killed and wounded! A few such victories would ruin us.”–Journal of Surgeon Alfred L. Castleman.

September 12, 2011

Journal of Surgeon Alfred L Castleman.,The American Civil War

12th.—Part of the truth relating to the story of yesterday’s fight has come to light. The fact is, these “great fights,” “great victories,” “great number of prisoners,” “great numbers killed,” are the greatest humbugs of the times, and as a specimen I put on record here the stories with the facts of yesterday. At 8 o’clock A. M. a body of soldiers passed up the turnpike. They were followed by batteries of artillery, and a few companies of cavalry. What does all this mean? was asked. And everyone wishing to be wise, an answer was soon manufactured satisfactory “to all concerned.” “Four thousand infantry and artillery had passed (Lie No. 1, there were only 2,000), to take a fort about seven miles off.” (Lie No. 2, there was no fort near.) About 12 o’clock we began to hear frequent reports of artillery, and by 2 P. M. the firing was brisk, and we could see the smoke of the shells exploding in the air from four to five miles away. About 3 o’clock we got orders to march on double-quick to the support of our troops, who were said to be retreating. (Truth No. 1.) Off we went on a full run, all vieing to see who could get there first. We had gone about a mile, when we were told to push forward, that one of our regiments was surrounded and being cut to pieces. (Lie No. 3.) On we went for another half mile, when “Halt, the rebels are retreating,” (lie No. 4,) and in a few minutes, “We must change our position, for the rebels were flanking us.” (Lie No. 5.) A few minutes later, our officers ordered us back to camp; we had gained a great victory. (Lie No. 6.)

Now these are the generalities of statements of the “great victory” of yesterday, which are being proclaimed to-day loud-mouthed. Let me put here the particulars, that in future when I hear of our great victories, I may refer to these, and draw some conclusion as to the probability of their truth.

In the morning, about two thousand men from Gen. Smith’s division, with a few pieces of artillery, passed up the pike to reconnoitre, in other words to examine the country and to ascertain what they could of the whereabouts of the enemy. They made their reconnoissance and started for camp. When they had marched about a quarter of a mile on their return, the rebels opened fire on them from a masked battery. Our artillery replied quickly and with spirit, our shot and shell mowing down hazels, oak grubs and saplings. These’ were all the enemy they saw. But above the heavy brush, in which the enemy’s batteries were masked, the smoke from their guns could be distinctly seen, and into this brush we fired without knowing the effects of our shot, though it is said that we silenced their battery. After about an hour thus spent our force retired, with the loss of some twenty or thirty men in killed and wounded, without capturing the battery which they had silenced, or without taking time to bring away even our own killed and wounded! What a “glorious victory!” So glorious that we must rush back to camp to announce it, leaving the enemy to look after our killed and wounded! A few such victories would ruin us. Gen. McClellan visited us to-day; made a speech, and promised us the luxury of a fight soon unless the rebels run. The appreciation of his kind promise was manifested by most unmistakable signs of joy.

Previous post:

Next post: